8 High Protein Shrimp and Seafood Recipes for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving table with high protein shrimp and seafood recipes — garlic herb shrimp skewers, shrimp cocktail, seared scallops and Cajun shrimp boil
8 high protein shrimp and seafood recipes for thanksgiving — 20–30g protein per serving.

Shrimp and seafood bring something different to the Thanksgiving table — lighter than turkey, faster to cook, and just as festive. A shrimp boil turns dinner into an occasion, a shrimp cocktail is the classic starter done lighter, and every recipe below is a high protein shrimp and seafood recipe for thanksgiving from spoonnspice.com, with 20–30g protein per serving (estimates). Put two or three out as starters, or make one the main for a small table.

1. Pumpkin Cream Sauce Shrimp High Protein Fall Dinner — 30g Protein

Plump shrimp simmered briefly in a silky sauce of pumpkin purée, cream, garlic and sage — 30g of protein per serving, one skillet, and dinner on the table in 30 minutes. Serves 4.

Pumpkin Cream Sauce Shrimp High Protein Fall Dinner

2. Garlic Herb Shrimp Skewers Thanksgiving Appetizer — 28g Protein

Plump shrimp marinated in garlic, lemon, parsley and olive oil, then grilled in minutes — charred at the edges, and on the table in 30 minutes while the turkey still has an hour to go. Serves 6.

Garlic Herb Shrimp Skewers Thanksgiving Appetizer

3. High Protein Shrimp Cocktail with Greek Yogurt Sauce — 26g Protein

The classic Thanksgiving starter, lightened up — chilled shrimp poached gently, then served with a creamy, tangy Greek yogurt sauce with lemon, dill and a little horseradish, instead of the usual sugary cocktail sauce. Serves 6.

High Protein Shrimp Cocktail with Greek Yogurt Sauce

4. Cajun Shrimp Boil Healthy Thanksgiving Week Version — 30g Protein

Shrimp, corn, baby potatoes and turkey sausage simmered in one big pot with Cajun seasoning, then tipped out onto the table — a fun, hands-on dinner with 30g of protein per serving. Serves 4.

Cajun Shrimp Boil Healthy Thanksgiving Week Version

5. Thanksgiving Seafood Stuffing with Shrimp High Protein — 28g Protein

The classic Thanksgiving side with a coastal upgrade — plump shrimp folded into golden toasted bread cubes with celery, onion, sage and thyme, baked in one dish with a crisp top and a soft, savoury middle. Serves 4.

Thanksgiving Seafood Stuffing with Shrimp High Protein

6. Crab Stuffed Mushrooms High Protein Holiday Appetizer — 20g Protein

Large mushroom caps filled with sweet lump crab, cream cheese, Greek yogurt and Parmesan, baked until the tops turn golden — a starter that looks fancy and takes almost no effort. Serves 6.

Crab Stuffed Mushrooms High Protein Holiday Appetizer

7. Seared Scallops over Butternut Squash Puree — 30g Protein

Plump sea scallops with a golden caramelised crust, served on a silky roasted butternut squash puree finished with brown butter and crispy sage — an elegant plate that feels restaurant-special. Serves 4.

Seared Scallops over Butternut Squash Puree

8. Shrimp and Cauliflower Grits Fall Comfort Meal — 30g Protein

Plump shrimp sautéed with garlic, butter and a little lemon, spooned over creamy cauliflower grits with sharp cheddar — all the comfort of classic shrimp and grits, and dinner on the table in 40 minutes. Serves 4.

Shrimp and Cauliflower Grits Fall Comfort Meal

How to choose your shrimp or seafood recipe

  • A proper centrepiece: the Cajun shrimp boil or the pumpkin cream sauce shrimp — both serve 4 and feed a small table.
  • Starters while guests wait: the garlic herb shrimp skewers, the shrimp cocktail or the crab stuffed mushrooms — all ready in 25–40 minutes.
  • Short on time: the shrimp cocktail (25 minutes) or the pumpkin cream sauce shrimp (30 minutes, one skillet).
  • Something different: the Thanksgiving seafood stuffing with shrimp — the classic side, with shrimp folded in.

FAQ

Do I need a whole turkey for Thanksgiving?

No. A Cajun shrimp boil or a pumpkin cream sauce shrimp gives you a proper Thanksgiving main for a small gathering, cooks in 30–40 minutes, and leaves far fewer leftovers to manage.

Which shrimp or seafood recipe has the most protein?

The pumpkin cream sauce shrimp, the Cajun shrimp boil, the seared scallops and the shrimp and cauliflower grits, all at 30g protein per serving (estimate). The garlic herb shrimp skewers and the seafood stuffing follow at 28g per serving (estimate).

Can I make these shrimp and seafood recipes ahead?

The shrimp cocktail can be poached and chilled hours ahead, and the seafood stuffing can be assembled ahead and baked when guests arrive. The skewers, scallops and pumpkin cream sauce shrimp are best cooked fresh — they only take 25–40 minutes.

What should I serve with a shrimp or seafood main?

Any of the high-protein sides on spoonnspice.com — roasted fall vegetables, mashed cauliflower, or a green bean casserole. Keep the plate simple: the seafood, one starchy side, one green side.

More high-protein recipes to try

Conclusion

A small Thanksgiving does not need a whole turkey to feel like Thanksgiving. Any of these eight high protein shrimp and seafood recipes for thanksgiving gives you a proper spread — plump shrimp, golden scallops and 20–30g protein per serving — without the all-day bird. Pick the one that fits your time and your table, and let the pan do the rest.